Research Catalog

Title

Deciding together : bioethics and moral consensus / Jonathan D. Moreno.

Author

Moreno, Jonathan D.

Publication

New York : Oxford University Press, 1995.

Items in the Library & Off-site

Holdings

Details

Description

xv, 165 pages; 24 cm

Summary

• .
• After outlining the current bioethical consensus, the book gives philosophical and political analyses of the idea of consensus, then assesses the role of consensus in national ethics commissions and in the ethics committee movement. Moreno constructs an original, naturalistic philosophy of moral consensus, referred to as "bioethical naturalism", and then applies sociology and social psychology to actual consensus processes. The book concludes with an account of bioethics as a consensus-oriented social reform movement.
• It has helped frame issues of moral values and medicine as part of a more general effort to find consensus about some of the most perplexing questions of our time. But why is it thought that a moral consensus is important or that it deserves respect? How does moral consensus acquire legitimacy in a society that includes diverse value systems? How is moral consensus possible and how do small groups help create or distort consensus processes?
• This insightful volume will be essential reading for bioethicists, philosophers, physicians, members of ethics committees, and all those concerned with ethical and social issues in health care.
• Western society today is less unified by a set of core values than ever before. Undoubtedly, the concept of moral consensus is a difficult one in a liberal, democratic and pluralistic society. But it is imperative to avoid a rigid majoritarianism where sensitive personal values are at stake, as in bioethics. Bioethics has become an influential part of public and professional discussions of health care.
• Written by a medical school professor trained in philosophy, this timely work tackles these questions from philosophical, historical, and social scientific standpoints. It begins by describing the traditional ambivalence about consensus in Western culture as well as the uncertain relationship in modernity between consensus and expertise.

Subjects

• Ethics Committees
• Ethics committees
• Bioethics

Bibliography (note)

• Includes bibliographical references and index.

Contents

• 1. The Challenge of Consensus for Bioethics. Consensus, Expertise, and Moral Authority in the Life Sciences. The Institution of Bioethics. The Nexus of Autonomy and Consensus in Bioethics. Consensus and Bioethics. Consensus and Controversy. Scrutinizing Bioethical Consensus -- 2. Consensus in Bioethics: Problems and Prospects. A New Moral Consensus. Consensus in Bioethical Theory. The Informed Consent Consensus. Beyond Informed Consent. The Research Ethics Consensus. Research Ethics and Women of Reproductive Age. Moral Consensus and Health Care Policy. Ethics and Cost Constraints in Health Care Policy. Continuing Challenges for Consensus in Bioethics. Ethics Committees and the Future of the Bioethical Consensus -- 3. Analyzing Consensus. Of Philoctetes and Proteus. Procedural and Substantive Consensus. Descriptive and Prescriptive Consensus. Consensus as Process and as Product. Consensus and Compromise. Metaphysics and Moral Consensus. Levels of Consensus. Affirming Consensus.
• 4. Liberalism and the Moral Authority of Consensus. Consensus and Liberalism. The Idea of an Overlapping Consensus. Extending Moral Consensus. The Problem of Representation. Ethics Experts and Democratic Deliberation -- 5. National Ethics Commissions. Consensus Panels in Medical Science. A Brief History of Governmental Commissions. The National Commission. The President's Commission. Governmental Ethics Commissions and Political Processes. Ethics Commissions and the Limits of Liberalism -- 6. Healthcare Ethics Committees. The Healthcare Ethics Committee Movement. Ethics Committees as Committees. Toward a History of Ethics Committees. Quinlan: Appearance and Reality. The President's Commission Report and "Baby Doe" Statutory Authority for Ethics Committees -- 7. Naturalizing Moral Consensus. Beyond the Political Rationale. Toward a Bioethical Naturalism. The Naturalistic Roots of Consensus. The Psychology of Moral Consensus. A Naturalistic Philosophy of Moral Consensus.
• Witnessing Consensus Processes in the Clinic. Moral Consensus and Natural Habitats -- 8. Small Groups and Social Practices. Philosophical Models of Group Consensus. Group Process and Group Product. Applied Social Science and Small Group Decision Making. Georg Simmel's Small Group Theory. J. L. Moreno's Sociometry. Management Theory and Facilitated Processes. Witnessing Consensus. Keeping Bioethics Pure -- 9. Bioethics as Social Reform. Taking Consensus Seriously. Bioethics as Social Reform. Bioethics, the Moral Philosophy of Medicine, and Medical Ethics. Ethics Consultation. Ethics Consultation and Social Reform. The Demands of Consensus for Bioethics. The Limits of Consensus for Bioethics. The Dangers of Consensus for Bioethics. The Virtues of Consensus.

ISBN

019509218X

LCCN

94026756

Owning Institutions

Columbia University Libraries